Yes. If your town pages are the same page with the city name swapped, Google usually treats them as copies and shows one at most. Large batches of near-identical city pages can also fall under Google's doorway page spam policy. Each page needs real, specific content for that place, or it isn't doing any work for you.
When I audit a service business's website, one of the most common issues is the location pages. The business has a page for every town or region it covers, which is a good instinct. But the pages were built from one template: the same photos, the same paragraphs, and the only thing that changes is the town name.
To the owner, that's twelve pages. To Google, it's the same page twelve times.
People talk about a "duplicate content penalty," but Google has said that's mostly a misunderstanding. When it finds pages that are nearly identical, it usually picks one version to show and filters the rest out of results. So most of those town pages simply never appear.
There is a line you don't want to cross, though. Google's spam policies call out doorway pages, and they name this exact pattern: pages targeted at specific cities or regions that funnel people to one place, and substantially similar pages built to rank for similar searches. Pages that violate the spam policies can rank lower or be removed from results.
Either way, cookie-cutter pages aren't helping you.
Another common setup: every service in the menu links to the contact page. I understand why. The contact page is where you want people to end up.
But Google needs a page to show for each thing someone searches. If someone looks for a specific job you do and there's no page about it, there's nothing for Google to recommend. If you want to be found for something, it needs its own page, with the contact page one click away.
A good town or region page answers the questions someone in that place would actually have:
There's no magic word count, and Google doesn't publish one. A page needs enough to genuinely help someone in that town decide to call you. If you can't write anything about a place that's different from your other pages, that's a sign it doesn't need its own page yet. Start with the towns where you actually do the most work, and add more as you have real projects to show.
The cleanest setup is a hierarchy: a services page that links to each service page, and a service area page that links to your region and town pages. Link them from your menu or footer so people and Google can find them easily. Ten solid pages beat fifty thin ones.
This comes up a lot with businesses that serve more than one state or want clients from further away. Your homepage doesn't have to carry all the local targeting. It can stay focused on your brand and what you do, while dedicated location pages do the local work. Mentioning where you're based is still useful, and your Google Business Profile carries a lot of local weight on its own.
The key is that every state or region page is a real, useful page that's linked from your site, not a thin page tucked away just for search engines.
You can use the same layout. What has to change is the content: the work, the proof and the details for that place. A shared design is fine; shared paragraphs are the problem.
Usually it just filters the copies out. But large batches of near-identical city pages can fall under Google's doorway page policy, which can hurt how those pages rank or remove them.
For the services you want to be found for, yes. Smaller related services can share a page if it covers them properly.
Rewrite the important ones with real local content, and consider combining or removing the rest. If you remove pages that get traffic, redirect them to the closest relevant page.
This is how I build location pages for clients, and for Audway's own Maine, Portland and Gorham pages. If you'd like a second set of eyes on yours, I'm happy to look at them on a free discovery call.
One honest note: nobody can guarantee where a page will rank. Unique, useful pages are what give you a real shot.
Sources: Google Search Central, Spam policies for Google web search and Demystifying the duplicate content penalty.
This is the kind of thing we handle every day for local businesses. Here's where it lives on our side.
Free 30-minute consultation. No pressure, no jargon.
Just a straight conversation about what your business needs.